There really is no comparison here. Thieves dish soap puts all other dish soaps to shame. But... as I am a full-disclosure kind of girl, I need to tell you I had the same issue with this one as I did with the laundry soap. Bubbles. I don't need them in my toothpaste, I don't need them in my all-purpose or toilet cleaner, but I need them in my dish soap. You won't find very many here... when you eliminate chemicals and surfactants, you eliminate bubbles. So... if you can't live without them... you may not be thrilled with this cleaner. I have gotten over it... mostly. Once you notice how clean your dishes are, I'm sure you'll get over it, too.